The most likely alternative if the main ID is wrong. Used when a species is not seen clearly enough to confirm an ID but it's likely one of two possibilities.

Datatype: taxon
Created by: jon_sullivan jon_sullivan

Observations specifying this field

Observation Otherwise it's this species
  Hohere (Hoheria lyallii)

Photos / Sounds

What

Hohere (Hoheria lyallii)

Observer

shirleykerr

Date

January 9, 2014
  Mountain Ribbonwood (Hoheria glabrata)

Photos / Sounds

What

Mainland New Zealand Bellbird (Anthornis melanura ssp. melanura)

Observer

tony_wills

Date

September 4, 2017 04:28 PM NZST

Description

Blackbirds and tuis in the background, but what is the loudest call. Heard it repeated a few times at longish intervals. Either bellbird or tui I suppose.

  Tūī (Prosthemadera novaeseelandiae)

Photos / Sounds

What

Groundsels (Genus Senecio)

Observer

johnvandenhoeven

Date

September 4, 2017 12:14 PM NZST

Description

I'm unsure if this is S.lautus or S.sterquilinus which are both found in the area.

  Guano Groundsel (Senecio sterquilinus)

Photos / Sounds

What

Black-shouldered Shieldbug (Carpocoris purpureipennis)

Observer

carnifex

Date

May 20, 2017 01:05 PM CEST
  Carpocoris pudicus

Photos / Sounds

Observer

carnifex

Date

August 7, 2016 02:00 AM CEST
  Rhynocoris rubricus

Photos / Sounds

What

Mediterranean Katydid (Phaneroptera nana)

Observer

prunhel

Date

September 2, 2017 01:25 PM SAST
  Sickle-bearing Bush-Cricket (Phaneroptera falcata)

Photos / Sounds

No photos or sounds

What

False Killer Whale (Pseudorca crassidens)

Observer

sandy_ferguson

Date

June 2016

Description

About 1.00 p.m. a large pod of something, dolphins? was sighted making its way south into Port Levy to the seaward side of Horomaka Island. I counted at least 40, my partner thought she saw 60+ and possibly up to 100.

We, with the neighbour, rowed over to the island and observed them slowly swimming past the island. It was thought that there were long steaks of krill in the bay and they might be feeding on it. Not confirmed.

On the island, below us was one individual with its front/head on the rocks and blood in the water. Was it scratching itself? It eventually with effort, freed itself and swam off to join the pod. Another individual about 50 metres further along, was observed at the end of the island doing a similar act. It eventually backed off and lay on the surface, breathing hard. It was lying inverted (upside-down) at one point. It eventually sank and surfaced every minute or so to breath. It could have been there for 1/4 hour, maybe more, 1/2 hour? before it also turned and headed to the pod which had by now moved towards the head of the bay. Three powerboats stationed themselves between the pod and the head of the bay as we certainly didn't want a stranding as had happen a few years before with a pod of pilot whales.

They looked like long fin pilot whales but not realising the similarity of false killer whales we didn't make the critical observations to differentiate them.

The next day a pod of false killer whales was spotted off Waimairi Beach with 2 stranding, one of those dying and one eventually refloated.

http://www.stuff.co.nz/environment/80780429/No-sign-of-rescued-false-killer-whale-off-Christchurch-coast

http://www.stuff.co.nz/environment/80759818/stranded-whale-refloated-at-christchurchs-waimairi-beach

Considering the previously observed behaviour one presumes they could have been the same two observed on the edges of Horomaka Island.

  Long-finned Pilot Whale (Globicephala melas)
View more search options

Comments

This field is for those situations where you didn't get a (good) photo, but you're pretty confident it was one species (entered in the field "Probably this species"), and if you're wrong it would be this other species.

Keep in mind that the maps and default observation searches will still display your the main species name only. Please don't agree with the main species name, and make an observation "research grade", if you're instead agreeing that it's a species listed in the fields "Probably this species" or "Otherwise it's this species".

If both species you think it might be are in the same genus, please use the genus as your main ID. Otherwise, go however high up the taxonomic tree you need to go to find a common taxon that is the unambiguously correct ID.

Posted by jon_sullivan almost 8 years ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments